Sometimes a simple idea to improve a neighbourhood can become impossible because of interference, and so it is with the Muir Wood Field Path in Juniper Green.
Both the Currie Community Council and Juniper Green and Baberton Mains wanted the muddy track bordering a field between Bloomiehall Park and Muir Wood Road turned into a permanent, hard footpath and I was very supportive.
But I also backed the community councils’ clear view that lighting was not necessary, only the surface improvement, so as not to spoil the rural character of the area. An ecological impact study showed that while the upgrade would have minimal effect on wildlife, lighting would have a significant impact on birds and the four species of bats in the area.
Normally that would be enough to kill off any notion of installing lights, but Edinburgh Council officers seem intent on sticking to a blinkered policy of only approving such projects if accompanied with illumination, so walkers and cyclists can use them at night.
As far as I am aware a clear majority of locals oppose lighting, and I’m also told that parks officers don’t like lighting because it attracts gangs of youths and anti-social behaviour.
A “vocal minority” is being blamed for growing opposition, but from what I can gather the minority is a handful of officers. But what is the point of local consultation for small local projects if the views of community representatives can so easily be dismissed?
Never mind policy, they know their area best. And it ain’t Blackpool.
